AUTO REPAIRBUSINESS BROKERBook a call
Menu

Building vs. lease decision calculator

Compare the operating business and the real estate separately before combining the cash flows. A buyer who takes a lease must support market rent from shop earnings. If you keep the property, discount net rent and the eventual sale to today. An immediate sale-leaseback converts that rent stream into a current property price.

Your inputs

Your estimate

Shop and building sold together
$1,364,000
Lease to buyer and hold · present value
$1,395,160
Immediate sale-leaseback
$1,334,000
First-year net rent
$72,000
Discounted rent over hold
$382,248
Discounted net property sale
$542,912
  • Put market rent into the shop earnings used to set the leased shop price. Future rent grows at the entered rate and terminal value uses the next year’s net rent. No mortgage, tax, vacancy or separate sale expense beyond your inputs is included.
Your results at a glance

Compare the outputs below using one common scale.

Calculated results for Building vs. lease decision calculatorShop and building sold togetherLease to buyer and hold · present valueImmediate sale-leasebackFirst-year net rentDiscounted rent over holdDiscounted net property sale$0$1,395,160

Source: your worksheet inputs and the published methodology below. As of November 21, 2026.

Chart data and full results
Calculated outputs from the current inputs
Shop and building sold together$1,364,000
Lease to buyer and hold · present value$1,395,160
Immediate sale-leaseback$1,334,000
First-year net rent$72,000
Discounted rent over hold$382,248
Discounted net property sale$542,912
Assumptions and formulas

Compare before-tax, debt-free present values. Add the shop proceeds under each structure. For a hold, discount annual net rent and an exit value at the selected cap rate. For an immediate sale-leaseback, capitalize first-year net rent. Subtract selling costs when property is sold.

Default figures are illustrative. Replace them with figures for the same period and keep a copy of the supporting records.

This is an estimate, not an appraisal or valuation opinion.

Key takeaways

  • Use a different shop price when the buyer must pay rent.
  • Subtract owner-paid property expenses before capitalizing or discounting rent.
  • Compare the alternatives on a common before-tax, debt-free basis.

Which assets are you actually selling?

Separate the repair operation from its location. A business buyer can buy the customer relationships, equipment, inventory and operating systems while you keep the property. The same buyer might want both assets. A separate investor might also buy the building and lease it to the operating buyer. Each structure changes who owns the rent stream and who bears the long-term property obligations.

Begin with evidence for the operating price and the property price on their own. Get market rent for a comparable repair use, including the actual space, yard rights and equipment arrangements. A general warehouse rent may not reflect the requirements of an operating repair shop. Use the shop valuation estimator on earnings that include the occupancy cost faced by the operating buyer.

How does the hold alternative work?

Take annual rent less costs and reserves you expect to pay as landlord. Grow that net amount at your entered rate through the holding period. Discount each year’s net rent at your chosen return requirement. At the end, estimate property value from the following year’s net rent divided by your cap rate, subtract property selling costs and discount the resulting proceeds. Add the leased shop’s sale price to today’s value of the property cash flows.

A cap rate expresses annual net operating income as a share of property price. Your discount rate serves a different purpose by bringing future dollars back to today. A single long lease with one local tenant concentrates risk in that operator. If your future cash needs depend on the rent, test a higher required return, lower rent and additional property expenses. The tool does not separately schedule vacancies or a major remediation project.

What does a simple rent calculation reveal?

Illustrative composite — not a real client. An operating buyer offers $480,000 for the shop subject to a lease. Annual rent is $88,000, with $16,000 of landlord-paid costs and reserves. First-year net rent is $72,000. At a hypothetical 8% cap rate an investor would model a $900,000 property price before selling costs. The same shop under an expensive lease may command less than the seller expects.

Now compare keeping the property. You receive the shop sale proceeds today and exposure to the tenant over the full hold. If rent growth and property appreciation disappoint, the final sale can offset years of rent. If you sell the building now, you give up the future rent and tenant risk. Compare the results to a real property offer and discuss your own financing and tax consequences with advisors before choosing a structure.

What lease provisions can overturn the model?

Review permitted use, environmental obligations, responsibility for lifts and drains, improvements, renewal options, assignment and who repairs the roof or parking surface. A small change in rent may matter less than a landlord obligation to replace a costly system. Ask who pays for an environmental investigation and who controls access if a lender requests additional work.

  1. Reconcile the rent assumption to comparable properties and the proposed lease.
  2. Review operating maintenance, capital spending and reserves with the lease checklist.
  3. Obtain separate support for the property price and any outstanding mortgage payoff.
  4. Run your after-tax closing cash separately with the net proceeds tool and your CPA.

The guide to selling with or without the building helps you prepare both pieces for discussion with a buyer and lender. When your goal is dependable retirement income, compare the timing, risk and management burden of future rent with the certainty and reinvestment needs of cash at closing. The highest modeled present value may require obligations you would prefer to leave behind.

What risk are you taking if the buyer becomes your tenant?

Look at the tenant’s ability to pay rent under the same assumptions used to finance the operating purchase. A new operator may need to fund payroll and equipment while servicing acquisition debt. A lease payment that makes your property look valuable to an investor can leave the shop too little working cash. Reconcile both budgets before treating an attractive cap-rate result as achievable.

Consider the circumstances of a lease default. A building configured around lifts, drains and specialized electrical service may have a narrower set of replacement tenants than ordinary industrial space. Estimate the time and expense needed to relet it. Review who controls removed equipment, remediation obligations and any personal guarantee. Use qualified local counsel and an environmental professional for issues tied to the site.

If you keep the building, decide who will administer the lease, track insurance certificates and pay for capital items. Those duties have a cost even when you perform them yourself. Compare the value of having future rent with the value of leaving the property business completely. An outside investor’s lower but documented cash offer may suit you better than a long hold whose assumptions require perfect occupancy and no unexpected repairs.

What does a one-year hold look like beside an immediate property sale?

Suppose your shop can sell for $550,000 with the building or $525,000 as a tenant paying market rent. A local property buyer indicates $900,000 for the real estate in a combined transaction. Annual rent would be $96,000, and you expect $24,000 of annual landlord expenses. Enter an eight percent capitalization rate, zero rent growth, a ten percent discount rate, a one-year holding period and two percent property selling costs. The property generates $72,000 of first-year net rent. At an eight percent cap rate, that rent supports a $900,000 property value before selling costs.

The combined option returns $1,432,000 of modeled consideration after the $18,000 property selling cost. The immediate sale-leaseback returns $1,407,000 because the model uses the separate leased-business price of $525,000. Under the hold option, first-year net rent has a current value of about $65,455. The $882,000 net property sale at the end of year one has a current value of about $801,818. Adding the shop sale produces approximately $1,392,273 today. The three figures answer a comparison question before debt and tax. Your actual wire depends on the mortgage payoff, business debt and the transaction-specific settlement statement.

How can a cap-rate change shift the decision?

Keep the rent, expenses and leased shop price constant, but raise the capitalization rate to nine percent. A future buyer demanding a higher return will pay $800,000 for $72,000 of net rent. Immediate property selling costs at two percent are $16,000, leaving $784,000 of property proceeds. The immediate sale-leaseback falls to $1,309,000. The combined option still uses the independently entered $900,000 indication, so its result stays at $1,432,000. If the existing property indication would also change after a shift in market rates, update its field separately. The model cannot infer whether the quote is firm, expired or conditional.

This sensitivity can lead to a more focused conversation with an investor. Ask what rent term, tenant financial statements, permitted use, guarantees and renewal rights were assumed when they proposed the cap rate. A buyer willing to accept an eight percent return on a long lease with a strong tenant may ask for a different return on a short lease with weak financials. Put the resulting property price alongside the business earnings after rent. A higher rent can raise property value while leaving the operating buyer with less money for debt service.

Which expenses should you keep on the property side?

Start with the draft lease and list each obligation by payer. Real-estate taxes, roof repairs, exterior pavement, structural maintenance, insurance deductibles and replacement of property equipment can land on different parties. A lease described as triple net may still leave meaningful costs with the landlord. Ask the broker and counsel to identify exceptions. Use the property’s own expense history to estimate recurring cost and consider larger near-term work separately. A roof replacement due next summer cannot be funded automatically by entering the prior year’s small repair bill.

For a property you already own, compare the tax bill and insurance premium after a sale or new tenancy with the amounts you currently pay. A lender may require different coverage from the incoming operator. Verify who owns the in-ground lifts, waste-oil tanks and attached equipment, and who maintains or removes them at the end of the term. Those obligations influence both future cash and reletting cost. Include a documented allowance or a separate case where the responsibility is uncertain.

What makes a rent-hold forecast credible enough to act on?

Request financial statements for the tenant, evidence of proposed financing, the lease assignment rights and any guarantee. A new operator with a strong opening balance may still need cash through a seasonal repair slowdown. If missed rent would force you to draw personal funds to cover a mortgage, build a month-by-month cash budget outside the present-value worksheet. Test a vacancy interval, repair costs before a replacement tenant moves in and a lower terminal sale price. The standard calculation assumes uninterrupted net rent for the selected years.

When you choose a holding period, use a date at which you plausibly could sell the property. A seven-year holding plan supported by only a three-year lease relies on a renewal, a replacement tenant or a sale with uncertain remaining term. Label that assumption and request a separate quoted value for the shorter term. Your family or business partners can then compare the extra cash expected from holding with the years of tenant exposure, capital needs and management responsibility you would retain.

What else should you know?

Why enter two different shop sale amounts?

When the shop and building trade together, the agreement still needs support for each component. When the buyer signs a lease, rent reduces operating earnings and may affect what the buyer can finance. Enter a supportable shop-only price for each structure so you avoid counting the same dollars twice.

Does gross rent equal net operating income?

Look at the lease terms. If you pay property taxes, insurance, roof reserves or other ownership expenses, subtract the relevant amounts before estimating the property’s income. Even a lease described as triple net can leave you with meaningful owner obligations. Review the actual language and expense history.

What happens to the building at the end of the hold?

The calculator projects the next year’s net rent and divides it by your exit cap rate. It then reduces that modeled sale price by property selling costs and discounts it to today. Actual pricing depends on tenant credit, remaining lease term, property condition and market conditions at sale.

Can a property investor’s offer change my business deal?

Yes. A new landlord may require a longer lease, guarantees, rent increases or different repair responsibilities. Those terms affect the operating buyer’s cash flow and financing. Compare both agreements together and ask your attorney to align the lease effective date, closing conditions and remedies.

Which sources can you check?

Explore the valuation hub

Recommended for you

Talk through your next move.

Bring your shop, your offer, or the question holding up your decision.

Book an intro call