Which number should you enter first?
Use the total consideration the buyer says you will receive if all terms pay out. Read the definitions page of the letter of intent before entering a number. A headline might include a maximum earnout, or the buyer may quote a fixed price plus an earnout. If the number excludes a contingent payment, bring it onto the same maximum basis as the other offer and label that adjustment in your notes.
Next split the price into note principal, maximum earnout, equity you keep in the buyer’s company and the amount held in escrow. The worksheet subtracts each from the headline. A holdback already inside a note cannot also go into the escrow field. If the buyer describes assumed debt as part of the price, reconcile that debt and its payoff outside the screen before comparing it to cash consideration.
A working-capital adjustment can change the closing check in either direction. Use the same sign as the closing statement. A shortfall against the agreed target reduces your cash, while an excess increases it to the extent the agreement provides. Separate the estimate used at closing from a later settlement. If the target is still being negotiated, model the disputed amount instead of quietly assuming it will wash out.
Illustrative composite — not a real client. A buyer offers $500,000, including a $60,000 note and a $20,000 holdback. Your estimated working-capital shortfall is $8,000. You would receive $500,000 − $60,000 − $20,000 − $8,000 = $412,000 before debt payoff, fees or tax. If the buyer releases the escrow later, that release is a future receipt. Use the net proceeds worksheet to connect this closing amount to your personal cash plan.
How do you compare money due later?
Pick a discount rate and collection horizon you can explain. A dollar tied up for years has less spending power today even when the buyer pays on time. In this screen all deferred value settles at the end of the selected period. The chart shows how much of each offer comes from your immediate check and how much comes from the present value of the expected balance.
Read the earnout formula itself. A revenue target can be sensitive to where a consolidator books fleet work after closing. A margin target can change when group charges hit your former location. Ask who controls staffing, pricing, routing and the definition of revenue. Assign a probability after reviewing those rights, and ask your attorney to check your information and dispute rights. A weight you cannot explain is a sensitivity to test, not a forecast.
Which assumptions deserve a second version?
Stress the promise you understand least. A rollover in a private platform may have a quoted face value while distributions depend on performance, debt and a future exit. The base model uses your entered rollover amount at the selected collection date. To see a lower recovery, make a separate copy with an explicit write-down and a correspondingly adjusted headline so your closing cash stays correct.
- Save the LOI and summarize each signed or proposed payment term.
- Record the working-capital definition and any later settlement dates.
- Compare the base, downside and closing cash measures on a single page.
- Document any claim, tax or interest item left outside the simplified screen.
Use the LOI comparison workbook to preserve the actual terms and ask the buyer how it expects to finance them. A buyer debt-service screen helps you see why a lender might require standby. Review the seller financing guide before agreeing to a note that must wait behind senior debt.
How do you check the value of a deferred promise?
Start with collection rights. A note may have a stated interest rate but allow the senior lender to suspend payments. A rollover certificate may restrict transfers or give other investors priority in a sale. An escrow can require an affirmative release signed by both sides. Ask the people drafting the documents to show when payment becomes enforceable and which events can delay it.
Make a calendar for each offer showing the close, first scheduled note payment, first earnout measurement date and proposed escrow release. Put the performance report, payment notice or other evidence beside the appropriate date. That calendar often exposes mismatched assumptions. A seller who plans to leave in six months may be accepting an earnout measured from operations they cannot observe two years later.
Separate the expected outcome from the amount you would need to collect to justify the harder offer. If another buyer offers a smaller but nearly all-cash deal, calculate the deferred collections required to beat it in today’s dollars. Then ask yourself whether the difference pays for the time, exposure and work the second contract demands. Keep the buyer’s proposed terms with the calculation so your next counteroffer addresses an actual gap.
What happens when a smaller offer crosses the finish line sooner?
Use two offers and a common ten percent discount rate. A strategic buyer proposes $800,000, with $100,000 in a seller note, a $100,000 earnout, $50,000 of rollover equity and a $30,000 escrow. Set its earnout probability at fifty percent, enter zero for the working-capital adjustment and give all deferred amounts a two-year horizon. A local buyer proposes $725,000, with a $25,000 escrow released after one year and no note, earnout, rollover or working-capital adjustment. These are invented terms you can enter one by one.
The strategic buyer delivers $520,000 in immediate cash. Its $230,000 of assumed deferred recovery comprises the note, the probability-weighted earnout, the rollover and the escrow. Dividing by 1.10 squared gives approximately $190,083 today. The total expected present value is $710,083. The local buyer pays $700,000 now and its escrow adds about $22,727 in present value, for a total of $722,727. The second bid leads on both immediate cash and the stated time-adjusted assumptions, even though its headline price is $75,000 lower. You can see the size of the trade without deciding in advance which buyer you prefer.
Which change would reverse that order?
Raise only the strategic earnout probability from fifty to one hundred percent. Its expected present value rises to approximately $751,405. The extra $50,000 of assumed collection is worth about $41,322 today at a two-year horizon. Cash at close stays at $520,000. If you need $650,000 immediately to pay debt and fund retirement, a larger expected value may still leave a gap. Ask whether the bidder could shift dollars from the earnout to closing cash, obtain a lender-approved guarantee or shorten the measurement period. Put any revision into a fresh copy so you can identify exactly which negotiated term created the improvement.
The probability field applies only to the earnout. If you think the buyer’s note is unlikely to be repaid, the expected column does not independently price that default. Read the downside column and then build a separate recovery schedule from the security agreement, expected collateral proceeds and senior debt position. A rollover presents yet another question. Minority ownership may have no fixed redemption date, and a later preferred financing could change the distribution waterfall. The selected date and face value give you a comparison convention. They need support from the proposed equity documents before you rely on them.
How do you prevent a working-capital adjustment from distorting your comparison?
Ask both bidders to define the target and sample calculation using the same month-end balance sheet. One may exclude aged fleet receivables, while the other may take inventory only after deducting obsolete tires. Imagine the local buyer’s calculation requires a $35,000 reduction and the strategic offer keeps its original balance. Enter negative $35,000 for the local adjustment because it reduces the seller’s cash. The local buyer would now pay $665,000 immediately. Its escrow would still be $25,000, because changing the working-capital line does not rewrite the agreed escrow. If the contract uses an estimate at closing and a later true-up, identify which portion is paid on which date.
A common error is entering the total price net of escrow, then entering the escrow again. Rebuild the headline from its pieces before comparing. If a buyer says “$700,000 cash plus a $25,000 holdback,” read the draft and confirm whether $725,000 is actually due. Use a single settlement sheet for each bidder with a separate section for expenses, lender payoffs and taxes. Those cash uses can determine the better personal outcome even when they do not form part of the offer itself.
Which questions belong with your response to each bidder?
For the earnout, specify how warranty credits, rate changes, new equipment expense, manager pay and acquired locations affect measurement. For escrow, identify claim deadlines, release instructions and treatment of disputed amounts. For a note, obtain the interest, amortization, maturity and subordination terms. A thirty-six-month amortizing note and a three-year balloon can have different present values even at the same face amount. Use the actual installment schedule outside this simplified common-date calculation when that difference could change your choice.
Finally, ask when each buyer has to produce financing evidence and whose consent is still required. A delayed landlord decision can shift the entire schedule. Save your assumptions next to the dated offer, then revisit them after diligence instead of carrying an old probability or release date into the final agreement.