What question should your quality-of-earnings review answer?
Start with the decision you need to make. A working technician considering an owner-operated purchase might want to know how much cash remains after replacing the seller’s counter duties. A multi-site buyer may need to know whether the shop earns a repeatable return after paying a manager and lead technician. A lender focuses on repayment. Define the buyer role, period, accounting basis and earnings measure before asking an accountant to inspect records. A number labeled adjusted earnings can look convincing while answering the wrong question.
Write a scope covering sales verification, gross margin, payroll, owner responsibilities, adjustments, working capital, capital expenditure and significant customer or vendor concentration. Identify items needing a different expert, including tax exposure, environmental issues and legal ownership. Ask what records the accountant can access and what the work will produce. A transaction review has different objectives and assurance from a financial statement audit. Use the shop management report request to obtain the operational records that ordinary financial statements cannot supply.
How do you establish dependable monthly financial records?
Get monthly income statements and balance sheets, the detailed general ledger, tax returns, trial balances, bank statements, merchant statements, payroll reports and the shop management exports. Request the same entity and date range across material sources. Look for operating expenses posted to another company, property expenses sitting inside the repair company and owner transfers coded as sales. Ask whether books are maintained on a cash, accrual or tax basis and whether annual year-end adjustments have been pushed down to individual months.
Make a change log. A new shop system, accounting software migration, ownership change, pandemic-related relief, added fleet contract or change in accounting method can produce a break in monthly trends. Mark the date and ask how older transactions were migrated. Keep original read-only exports with report settings and extraction dates. IRS recordkeeping guidance explains the role of records supporting income, expenses and assets. For a QOE, your objective is the ability to reproduce the figures and trace the important assumptions when new information arrives.
How do you reconcile repair orders through the bank?
Start with closed repair orders for a selected month. Split labor, parts, tires, sublet, fees, credits, discounts, sales taxes and internal or warranty tickets according to how the system posts them. Reconcile net sales to the general ledger. Then explain the gap between sales and receipts using receivables, customer deposits, timing, refunds, cash payments, payment processing and other reconciling items. Merchant deposits often arrive net of fees or grouped across several days. Cash collected and cash deposited can also differ for reasons the seller must document.
Follow complete transactions through the chain. Select ordinary retail tickets, fleet invoices, a large sublet job, a refund, an open order crossing month-end and a warranty return. Trace the approved work through the invoice, payment and ledger. Verify how the shop accounts for parts that arrived before a repair closes. A seller can produce an accurate annual sales number while monthly earnings are distorted by recording revenue in one month and parts cost in the next. The repair order to bank framework shows how to keep these bridges separate.
What can gross margin and labor records reveal?
Compute gross profit by service line using consistent definitions. A tire-heavy month, diagnostic project or large subcontracted engine job can shift margins without changing pricing discipline. Match selected vendor invoices and credits to repair orders. Identify core credits, volume rebates, returns and freight. Ask whether a supplier rebate recorded at year-end relates to the entire year and whether the buyer will qualify. If the same rebate reduces parts cost on the invoice and also appears as other income, investigate potential duplication.
Compare payroll rosters and time records with produced hours. Identify the owner, family members, technicians, service advisers, administrative staff and anyone paid through another entity. Calculate actual loaded compensation and test missing overtime, temporary staffing or recent wage changes with appropriate advisers. Billed hours are a production measure. Paid and worked hours have different uses. A productivity dashboard cannot establish payroll completeness on its own. Review the latest staff changes because the last twelve months might include time from a diagnostician who has already left.
Shop QOE tests and what each can establish| Test | Primary evidence | Question for the report |
|---|
| Sales completeness | Closed orders, ledger and deposits | Can material monthly variances be explained? |
| Margin quality | Vendor costs, credits and payroll | Which earnings reflect a durable service mix? |
| Normalization | Invoices, roles and proposed contracts | What cost continues for the buyer? |
| Cash conversion | Aging, inventory, capex and settlement | When does profit become spendable cash? |
What does one corrected earnings bridge look like?
Illustrative composite — not a real client. A seller presents $280,000 of owner-operator earnings. Your review finds $22,000 included for a supposedly removable family role. The family member handles accounts payable and fleet submissions, and your replacement estimate is $15,000. If the $22,000 was already added in the starting figure, deduct the $15,000 replacement cost to reach $265,000. A new signed lease increases annual rent by $9,000, bringing the buyer case to $256,000.
The latest financial year also included a $12,000 parts credit posted in January. Documents establish the credit relates to purchases throughout that same financial year and should recur on buyer terms under the same volumes. You leave the annual total intact and redistribute it only for monthly trend analysis if appropriate. The buyer also faces $28,000 of immediate compressor work. Record that cash separately. Deducting $28,000 as though the compressor failed every year would produce a different and unsupported earnings assumption. Use the SDE recast tool for the adjustments and a separate schedule for cash.
Why can recurring earnings still produce a cash squeeze?
Examine receivable collections, inventory buildup, payables timing, duties on open orders, repair deposits and capital expenditure. A busy fleet shop can grow reported sales and still need cash if it pays technicians weekly while fleets pay later. Compare the working capital the business historically needed with the assets and liabilities the buyer actually receives. If the seller keeps receivables, the buyer must finance the first postclosing cycle. Identify opening payroll, parts-order deposits, rent, taxes and debt payments on actual dates.
Look at maintenance records alongside depreciation. A shop may have deferred rack repairs, lift replacement or software upgrades while the seller prepared to exit. Ask which expenditure preserves existing capacity and which expands it. Use installed quotes, downtime and timing to model cash requirements. Check whether your buyer forecast already includes the same work. The value discussion may need separate treatment for an earnings adjustment, an opening cash shortfall and an investment you choose to improve the business beyond its present state.
Which steps turn a review into a buying decision?
- Reconcile monthly and annual records with the operational systems, tax filings and collection evidence for the same entity.
- Sample both ordinary and unusual transactions, including refunds, fleet authorizations, month-end work and supplier credits.
- Test owner duties, staffing and occupancy under the buyer’s actual operating plan and signed or proposed agreements.
- Present verified adjustments, unresolved amounts and buyer-specific savings separately, each with supporting evidence.
- Model the effects on valuation, financing capacity and opening cash. Decide what needs confirmation before closing.
Ask for a short exceptions register describing the missing record, potential size, responsible party and consequence if unresolved. Some findings affect price, others require a condition to closing, and smaller items can be accepted with a documented rationale. Use the valuation hub to connect the verified earnings range with the decision that prompted your review.
Which old numbers still matter after a strong recent quarter?
Trace the recent improvement to price, job count, average repair order, service mix and available technician hours. Separate genuine operating changes from invoicing timing or a single backlog release. Compare the same months across years, then inspect customer concentration and the capacity needed to sustain the new level. Ask what your buyer team must spend or change to keep it. A profitable quarter can improve a case once you understand the repeatable mechanism.
Which month should you inspect after the closing date?
Ask for the first available subsequent bank and vendor statements during diligence. A large payment received early the next month can confirm a prior invoice, while a credit issued just after period-end can change the reported margin on your selected job. Use the original invoice date, credit reason and underlying service date to identify which period is affected. Review your work with the accountant before changing figures. A subsequent event can corroborate historical information, disclose a new issue or simply reflect ordinary settlement timing.
What should you do when the review cannot resolve a discrepancy?
Describe the uncertainty in plain language and calculate the upper and lower effects where possible. Avoid treating unexplained receipts as normalized earnings or assuming every missing invoice represents fraud. Ask which specific document, vendor statement or independent check could change the conclusion. If the remaining exposure exceeds your tolerance, adjust the structure, condition the purchase on resolution or reconsider the deal within your signed rights and deadlines.
What else should you know?
Is a QOE review an audit?
A transaction quality-of-earnings review is scoped to acquisition questions about earnings, risks and cash conversion. It does not by itself provide an audit opinion. Ask the accountant to define the work, period, access, evidence limits and deliverables, and clarify which matters require a separate tax, legal or accounting engagement.
Can a small buyer do an initial review alone?
You can organize records, reconcile sales and identify gaps before engaging specialists. Ask a qualified transaction accountant to address disputed accounting, timing, complex adjustments or risks material to your offer. Keep the initial review and professional conclusions distinct, and decide what must be resolved before financing or closing.
What if bank deposits exceed reported shop sales?
Identify loan proceeds, owner transfers, intercompany receipts, sales tax, customer deposits and collection of earlier invoices. Trace representative amounts to documentation. Bank deposits and repair-order revenue measure different events, so a variance needs an explanation before you treat it as evidence of unreported sales or stronger earnings.
Should owner replacement appear in the QOE?
Yes, when the buyer’s operating case requires duties the seller performs. Identify the hours, role, skills and fully loaded replacement cost, and state whether you are calculating owner-operator SDE or manager-run results. Present buyer-specific savings separately from the shop’s standalone earnings so both assumptions remain clear.